Difference between revisions of "3d-printer-compare"

From RevSpace
Jump to: navigation, search
m
Line 8: Line 8:
 
!Cartesio W1CE
 
!Cartesio W1CE
 
!Lulzbot TAZ 4
 
!Lulzbot TAZ 4
 +
!Ultimaker II
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Price
 
|Price
Line 13: Line 14:
 
|3600
 
|3600
 
|2195
 
|2195
 +
|€ 2300 incl. BTW
 
|-
 
|-
 
|PLA
 
|PLA
|Ja
+
|YES
 
|x
 
|x
|Ja
+
|YES
 +
|YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|ABS
 
|ABS
|Ja
+
|YES
 
|x
 
|x
|Ja
+
|YES
 +
|YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|PVA
 
|PVA
|Ja
+
|YES
 
|x
 
|x
|Ja
+
|YES
 +
|?
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Filament Diameter
 
|Filament Diameter
|3mm
+
|3 mm
|3mm
+
|3 mm
|3mm
+
|3 mm
 +
|2.85 mm
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Filament Temp
 
|Filament Temp
|150 tot 250 Cel.
+
|150 tot 250 °C
 
|x
 
|x
|max 240 cel.
+
|max 240 °C
 +
|180 - 260 °C
 
|-
 
|-
 
|File support
 
|File support
 
|stl, obj, gcode
 
|stl, obj, gcode
 
|x
 
|x
 +
|
 +
|STL / OBJ / DAE / AMF
 
|-
 
|-
|Max print speed
+
|Print speed
|180mm/sec
+
| -180 mm/s
|150mm/sec
+
| -150 mm/s
|200mm/sec
+
| -200 mm/s
 +
|30-300 mm/s
 
|-
 
|-
|Precision
+
|Accuracy*
 
|X,Y axis 0.0125 mm, Z axis 0.001 mm
 
|X,Y axis 0.0125 mm, Z axis 0.001 mm
 
|0,28 mm
 
|0,28 mm
 
|0,1 mm
 
|0,1 mm
 +
|0.0125 mm (X,Y), 0.005 mm (Z)
 
|-
 
|-
|Stepper Motor
+
|Stepper Motor*
 
|X, Y 42''48, 1.3A, Z 42''63, 1.5A
 
|X, Y 42''48, 1.3A, Z 42''63, 1.5A
 +
|x
 
|x
 
|x
 
|x
 
|x
 
|-
 
|-
|Controller
+
|Controller*
 
|Arduino Mega 2560 R3
 
|Arduino Mega 2560 R3
 
|x
 
|x
 
|open source
 
|open source
 +
|YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Linux
 
|Linux
|Ja
+
|YES
 
|x
 
|x
|Ja
+
|YES
 +
|YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Software
 
|Software
Line 72: Line 86:
 
|x
 
|x
 
|x
 
|x
 +
|Cura
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Extruders
 
|Extruders
Line 77: Line 92:
 
|max 4
 
|max 4
 
|max 1
 
|max 1
 +
|
 
|-
 
|-
|Max. print afmetingen
+
|Max. print dimensions
 
|250×250×300 mm
 
|250×250×300 mm
 
|400x200x200 mm
 
|400x200x200 mm
 
|297x274x248 mm
 
|297x274x248 mm
 +
|230x225x205 mm
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Extrude Nozzle
 
|Extrude Nozzle
Line 87: Line 104:
 
|x
 
|x
 
|0.075mm to 0.35mm
 
|0.075mm to 0.35mm
 +
|0.4 mm
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Hot bed
 
|Hot bed
|Ja
+
|YES
 
|x
 
|x
|Ja
+
|YES
 +
|50-100 °C
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Bed materiaal
 
|Bed materiaal
|Monocrystal glas
+
|Monocrystal glass
 
|x
 
|x
 
|Borosilicate glass bed covered with PET film
 
|Borosilicate glass bed covered with PET film
 +
|glass
 
|-
 
|-
|Afgesloten
+
|Closed printing area
 
|Ja
 
|Ja
 
|Ja
 
|Ja
 
|Nee
 
|Nee
 +
|closed sides, open front/top
 
|-
 
|-
|Afmetingen printer
+
|External dimensions
|380x420x530mm
+
|380x420x530 mm
 
|x
 
|x
|680x520x515mm
+
|680x520x515 mm
 +
|492x342x558 mm (incl. filament)
 
|-
 
|-
|Gewicht
+
|Weight*
 
|25kg
 
|25kg
 
|x
 
|x
 
|11kg
 
|11kg
 +
|YES
 
|-
 
|-
|Opmerkingen
+
|Notes
 
|x
 
|x
 
|Graveert ook
 
|Graveert ook
 
|Open source hardware & software, print ook nylon, Laywood, Laybrick & Ninjaflex
 
|Open source hardware & software, print ook nylon, Laywood, Laybrick & Ninjaflex
 +
|
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Link
 
|Link
Line 122: Line 146:
 
|http://mauk.cc/webshop/systems/cartesio-assembled/Cartesio-w1ce-assembled
 
|http://mauk.cc/webshop/systems/cartesio-assembled/Cartesio-w1ce-assembled
 
|https://www.lulzbot.com/products/lulzbot-taz-4-3d-printer
 
|https://www.lulzbot.com/products/lulzbot-taz-4-3d-printer
 +
|https://www.ultimaker.com/pages/our-printers/ultimaker-2
 
|}
 
|}
  
 
x = niet bekend
 
x = niet bekend
 +
* = unreliable or irrelevant  specification

Revision as of 15:19, 14 May 2014

3D printer vergelijking

Besproken op de metameet van 13x05x2014. Eerste model (Mankati) is via Rix, tweede model (Carteso) zit in maasstricht en Lulzbot onbekend.

Mankati Fullscale XT Cartesio W1CE Lulzbot TAZ 4 Ultimaker II
Price 2150 3600 2195 € 2300 incl. BTW
PLA YES x YES YES
ABS YES x YES YES
PVA YES x YES ?
Filament Diameter 3 mm 3 mm 3 mm 2.85 mm
Filament Temp 150 tot 250 °C x max 240 °C 180 - 260 °C
File support stl, obj, gcode x STL / OBJ / DAE / AMF
Print speed -180 mm/s -150 mm/s -200 mm/s 30-300 mm/s
Accuracy* X,Y axis 0.0125 mm, Z axis 0.001 mm 0,28 mm 0,1 mm 0.0125 mm (X,Y), 0.005 mm (Z)
Stepper Motor* X, Y 4248, 1.3A, Z 4263, 1.5A x x x
Controller* Arduino Mega 2560 R3 x open source YES
Linux YES x YES YES
Software MankatiUM (Based on Cura) x x Cura
Extruders max 2 max 4 max 1
Max. print dimensions 250×250×300 mm 400x200x200 mm 297x274x248 mm 230x225x205 mm
Extrude Nozzle 0,4 mm (0,3 en 0,5 beschikbaar) x 0.075mm to 0.35mm 0.4 mm
Hot bed YES x YES 50-100 °C
Bed materiaal Monocrystal glass x Borosilicate glass bed covered with PET film glass
Closed printing area Ja Ja Nee closed sides, open front/top
External dimensions 380x420x530 mm x 680x520x515 mm 492x342x558 mm (incl. filament)
Weight* 25kg x 11kg YES
Notes x Graveert ook Open source hardware & software, print ook nylon, Laywood, Laybrick & Ninjaflex
Link http://www.mankati.com/fullscale-xt.html http://mauk.cc/webshop/systems/cartesio-assembled/Cartesio-w1ce-assembled https://www.lulzbot.com/products/lulzbot-taz-4-3d-printer https://www.ultimaker.com/pages/our-printers/ultimaker-2

x = niet bekend

  • = unreliable or irrelevant specification